Skip to main content

weather icon
Mostly Cloudy, 68°
Weather sponsored by:
Business Spotlight: Your Pie Pizza

Todds remind community of Your Pie one slice at a time

Posted 11/19/26

FLEMING ISLAND — Jimmy and Tammy Todd were once customers of Your Pie Pizza. The fresh food and friendly atmosphere were things that drew them in. Not to mention the famous brick oven. So, imagine …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

Log in

Don't have an ID?


Print subscribers

If you're a print subscriber, but do not yet have an online account, click here to create one.

Non-subscribers

Click here to see your options for subscribing.

Single day pass

You also have the option of purchasing 24 hours of access, for $1.00. Click here to purchase a single day pass.

Business Spotlight: Your Pie Pizza

Todds remind community of Your Pie one slice at a time


Posted

FLEMING ISLAND — Jimmy and Tammy Todd were once customers of Your Pie Pizza.

The fresh food and friendly atmosphere were things that drew them in. Not to mention the famous brick oven. So, imagine the moment when they decided to purchase their own franchise on Fleming Island a few months ago.

"It's full circle," Jimmy said.

The casual restaurant at 1545 County Road 220 has remained a staple on the island for 13 years.  It's a place where customers are invited to express their inner pizza. And where they specialize in crafting hand-tossed, brick oven pies tailored to every taste. 

When the local family saw the store up for sale, it took didn't take much thought to procure it. Although they knew nothing about the industry, they jumped in at full speed ahead. And it's been nothing but a slice of heaven since, Jimmy said.

Pizza has always been a part of the family's life in one way or another, especially for their son who couldn't help but love the doughy dish. When they traveled, they would often try to find the best spots. Your Pie was on the list.

"We came all the time when he was little, the kids and I. And then we kind of actually forgot about it for about six years."

That's the exact sentiment Jimmy said they want to change. Their goal is to make sure the restaurant is as visible as possible, and that people don't forget the delicious products that they produce.

Like their signature customizable 10-inch pies, such as the Lineage Supreme topped with mushrooms, black olives and Italian sausage and pepperoni. Or the Italian and Chicken Caprese pizza shop sandwiches.

And you can't forget the assortment of oven friend wings, fresh salads, oven baked pastas, famous gelato desserts and selection of beers and wines.

"The product basically supports itself. It's just really good."

Your Pie Pizza was originally founded by Dave French after he first experienced authentic Italian cuisine after honeymooning on the island of Ischia in 2006. The first franchised opened in Athens, Georgia in 2008. Today, there are more than 70 locations throughout the United States.

It was the piping-hot traditional open-flame, brick oven that served as the main inspiration behind French's dream.

And that's what sets them apart, Jimmy said. Each dish is cooked to order at 700-800 degrees to a crisp finish. The unique down-the-line-concept also makes it easier to incorporate quality ingredients and keep a variety of options for those who want to switch up their palate. Toppings are always fresh and locally sourced. And their popular ranch dressings are made in house. 

 

Jimmy said his family has always wanted to work together. And although they are new to the restaurant business, it's been a great experience so far. He said his staff has been a driving force behind their success.

 

"They have a lot of relationships with the customers and they're really good at what they do. So that gave me a lot of confidence coming into a new industry I'd never been in before, because of the staff. I depend on them," Jimmy said.

 

 

The family and staff welcomed customers for an official grand reopening on Saturday, Nov. 14, equipped with a DJ, face painting, balloon animals and their choice of pizza.

 

Jimmy said it was the perfect time to reintroduce some menu favorites while also welcoming some new additions. Like the limited time Steakhouse Melt Sandwich, Wedge Salad, Garlic Pepper Wings, Black and Blue Pizza and Bourbon Butter Gelato.

While they are currently experimenting with a new spin on pan pizza, in the meantime Jimmy said customers can look forward to a dessert bar featuring some new favorites like their Affogatos.

 

 

Affogatos are a traditional Italian dessert comprising of a scoop of vanilla gelato topped with espresso. Your Pie Pizza Fleming Island is currently the only franchise with the offering.

 

All in all, Jimmy said they are hoping to bring a more local feel to the restaurant. Adding a fresh new spin on a tried-and-true recipe.  And for the Todds, that means feeding bodies with delicious food while also feeding their soul with a palpable atmosphere. One slice at a time.